Customer Rating: 



Review Summary: A Charming Portrayal of Immigrant Life
Review: Jin's superb writing skill is what makes this book so charming. It is a straightforward and often emotional narrative about Nan Wu, his wife Pingping, and their son Taotao, who emigrate from China to America after the Tiananmen Square massacre. Nan struggles to disengage himself from his former nationalism while pursuing the American dream for his family. He finds menial success doing different jobs in Boston and New York before relocating his family to Atlanta where he owns his first home and a business running a Chinese restaurant. His achievements are significant but Nan often considers himself a failure.
There are several reasons Nan is disillusioned with the life he created for himself. One is his reticence among other Chinese immigrants, whom he chooses to isolate himself from. Another is his unrequited former love, who still plagues his thoughts and prevents him from fully and passionately loving Pingping. But the true struggle is his writing. Nan wishes to be a poet more than anything, but finds his dissatisfaction of life a hindrance to his creativity. While he remains an ardent observer and marginal participant of literary life, he is often too harsh a critic of himself, especially in comparison to some of his fellow Chinese who have found some modest literary success. In the end, he chooses to abandon his native tongue and write solely in English, despite the criticism he receives.
This was a great story, documenting the day-to-day lives of the Wu family and their immersion into American society. Yes there were struggles, but many of these had more to do with Nan's perception than actual hardship. They do encounter some tragedy, but overall, their lives are full and they find solace in their devotion and loyalty to each other. Nan grows throughout the narrative, learning how to overcome his ineptitude at writing and even learning to love Pingping wholeheartedly. The novel flows and I couldn't help but be engaged with the Wu's story. I was touched by their lives and was given a new perspective on Chinese culture.
Customer Rating: 



Review Summary: Not his best
Review: This may be Ha Jin's "first American novel" but he is already well-established as a master of the English language. There can be no doubt that the storyline of this book must echo a substantial part of Jin's own life, especially the literary references he often makes. The weakness of this novel is that it lacks dramatic tension, unlike "Waiting" which was gripping and "War Trash" which was harrowing.
I am a huge fan of Ha Jin's writing, but I submit he is not being well served by his editor. I don't think it's necessary to dissect the problems in this review, but both "War Trash" and "A Free Life" are much longer than need be.
Do I recommend this? Most definitely. But Jin needs to reflect on what made "Waiting" such a magnificent novel.
Customer Rating: 



Review Summary: a story that doesn't really end
Review: I picked up this book based upon reading reviews. While the first portion of the book is interesting and reminds me of the many struggles of immigrant Chinese in America, the later part of the book just stops without a true ending. This might be ok in some circumstances but then the epilogue doesn't really seem to make much of a difference.
Customer Rating: 



Review Summary: Endlessly Interesting and Beautifully Written
Review: I love how this book works through the immigrant experience on several levels. The main character worries about the details of everyday life in America, but he's also dealing with mixed emotions about his homeland and his dream of becoming a writer. The book is painfully honest about the choices he has to make to provide a better life for his family and adapt to a new homeland. It also goes into depth about his creative process and his struggle to balance monetary stability with his artistic impulses. Just an engrossing story all around.
Customer Rating: 



Review Summary: Everybody Whines
Review: That Ha Jin is a master of prose is undisputed. That he chose to use his talent to painstakingly chronicle the quotidian lives of an immigrant couple from China is unfortunate. That his characters whine about many of the same things as other Americans is noteworthy in the first three chapters. But an entire novel?